Every data point is a person

Are our data systems designed to understand people, or just to measure them?

The Data Human Index scores brands on five dimensions: transparency, consent, clarity, control and empathy. Every score is published with the reasoning behind it, so it can be argued with rather than simply believed.

Facebook, scored on the five dimensions of the Data Human Index. Ten out of twenty, and the shape says more than the number.

The Data Human Index

How human does a brand's data experience actually feel?

Most brands say they respect your data. The Index measures whether they actually do, using only what any user can observe, in about twenty minutes. One question per dimension, scored zero to four, no inside access required.

01

Transparency

How many clicks to the privacy policy?

02

Consent

Are accept and decline equally easy?

03

Clarity

Could a person actually read it?

04

Control

How many clicks to delete your account?

05

Empathy

Can you reach a human?

0–7 Extraction-first

Data practices are built around the brand's needs. Expect dark patterns, buried controls and walls of legal text.

8–13 Compliance-bound

Genuine effort is visible but gaps remain. You can navigate it, but you have to work for it.

14–18 Trust-aware

Real care across most dimensions with one or two weaknesses. Thinking about experience, not just compliance.

19–20 Human-centred

Transparent, respectful and genuinely designed with the user in mind. Data as a relationship, not a resource.

Score a brand yourself

Real scores, real brands

Same industry. Completely different stories.

Facebook and TikTok, a point apart on the total and nothing alike in shape. Scored one dimension at a time, in a private browser window, using only what any visitor can see.

Facebook
10/20 · Compliance-bound

Ceiling scores on Transparency and Clarity. Floor scores on Consent and Control. The information is there but the power is not.

TikTok
11/20 · Compliance-bound

The only brand in the dataset to score zero on any dimension, yet account deletion is easier here than almost anywhere we have scored.

The score is just the starting point. The shape is where the story is.

See the evidence behind every number

Latest writing

Short essays on behaviour, trust and the human side of data

Where data-driven systems succeed, where they fall short, and why so many experiences feel out of sync with what people actually expect.

All writing